Re: past tense imperative

Hi!

René Uittenbogaard <ruittenb@...> writes:
> A couple of days ago, I was struck by an interesting grammatical construction
> in Dutch. Dutch has a construction in which an imperative can be used in
> the past perfect:
>
> Had dat dan gezegd!	- You should have told me so!
> Was dan niet gegaan!	- You shouldn't have gone!
Cool!  German cannot do that, that's for sure!  Very concise -- I
think I'll have to keep that it mind for conlanging.

It's a bit strange, of course, since the action contained it the
command is obviously already terminated, so 'imperative' is a strange
word here.

> AFAIK, in other languages, the imperative always seems to be used
> with the present tense.
>
> Are there other languages in which this phenomenon is known?
No idea.

**Henrik

Reply