Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: a verb aspect--what's it called?

From:dirk elzinga <dirk.elzinga@...>
Date:Tuesday, October 10, 2000, 20:51
Hey.

In "An American Indian Model of the Universe" Benjamin Whorf claims
that the most salient categorization in Hopi thought is between
"manifesting" and "manifested". Some more linguisticky terms might be
"potential" and "realized"; your "contemplative" seems to match
reasonably well with Whorf's "manifesting" category. He also speaks of
the inceptive as the grammatical marker for events which emerge from
the realm of the potential to the realm of the realized; your
progressive might fill that role.

So there are some terms: 'manifesting' (kinda New Agey) or 'potential'
(not precisely an aspect, but a bona fide linguistic term).

Dirk

On Tue, 10 Oct 2000, Yoon Ha Lee wrote:

> I've jotted down some notes for Meep, though it'll probably be developed > very slowly, and I came across a problem in how I want the verbs. > > I was hoping to have 3 aspects, no tenses-per-se, for verbs: > > contemplative (ad hoc name): an action that hasn't begun or is being > considered, or wished, or wondered about--something that hasn't > actually happened > progressive: an action that's happening or in progress > completive: an action that's been completed and tied off > > (Well, I guess the use of "is happening," etc. is deceptive. > Theoretically I'd like these to be useable in past, present or future. > Meep isn't intended to be a practical artlang, just whimsical.) > > I tried looking up a website article on aspects: > http://www.rick.harrison.net/langlab/aspect.html > > which is great in that it has a lot of neat examples (a number of which I > stole for Chevraqis), but couldn't find anything that corresponds to > "contemplative" (I thought it might be inchoative, but it seems not). > Does anyone know of an existing name for this sort of aspect, or should I > just stick with the ad hoc "contemplative"? > > YHL, wishing she could pick up Comrie's _Aspect_, except she's *frozen* > book acquisitions, darnit! >
-- Dirk Elzinga dirk.elzinga@m.cc.utah.edu