Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: Conlangs on based Slavic languages...etc

From:Costentin Cornomorus <elemtilas@...>
Date:Wednesday, September 10, 2003, 3:00
--- "Mark J. Reed" <markjreed@...> wrote:

> > > Indo-Hitite; according to some > > > linguisticians
> How is a "linguistician" different from a > "linguist"?
One knows more [bad] puns? :)
> > > Hittite is not an IE language, but is a > > > sister > > > language of IE. As far as the internal > > > history is concerned, it's simply "Aryan". > > > Of course, that is quite a silly definition. > > The very term 'Indo-European', > > AFAIK, means all the recorded languages in > > that family(that can be proven to > > be related). > > The term "Indo-European" refers to all the > languages descended from the > ancestor language "Proto-Indo-European". If > Hittite were a sibling of > PIE rather than a child, then it would not be > part of the I-E family.
I'm not sure I'd go quíte that far. I might say it's IE, but not descended from PIE. Either that, or the language everyone touts as PIE isn't quite proto enough to explain Hittite in relation to the other IE languages. Padraic. ===== - Per la maxam pas e drancoueletate di nusteor tempuroer; per l' echluys catholeg, ke 'sta di bille do bille et dol fine le munnem - A Ddon ten mezercorth! -- Come visit The World! -- <> .