Re: Reviving Wikipedia:Conlangs

On Jan 25, 2008 8:36 PM, Herman Miller <hmiller@...> wrote:
> The problem is the idea of "notability" is not well defined. So how does
> it make any sense to say that anything is "by definition" non-notable?
To clarify, I was here using (somewhat ironic) third-party voice. I do
not agree with this (and agree rather with your perspective) - but the
Wikipedia notability standards (e.g. WP:WEB) do seem to.

I personally absolutely oppose notability as a criterion except
narrowly for the purposes of decluttering high-profile areas, like
primary articles, lists of especially notable conlangs, and the like.

- Sai