Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: Ergativity Question

From:Thomas R. Wier <trwier@...>
Date:Wednesday, August 11, 2004, 20:36
I actually mispasted the text, and didn't finish responding to
this part of Caleb's post:

Caleb wrote:
> > Well, maybe. What morphological case the agent gets put in does not > > necessarily indicate that the agent has typical subject properties. > > That's the crux of the issue. > > I'm not quite sure what you mean. Could you clarify or give an example?
Well, for example, in some ergative languages the instrumental-themed argument and the agent-themed argument both receive ergative case, as in "John-ERG hit the target-ABS (with) an arrow-ERG", even though the second instance of morphological ergative case here is clearly not the subject of the sentence. Lak, a Daghestanian language, treats both possessors and agents of transitive verbs with the same case (usually called "genitive"). Again, in so-called "deep ergative" languages, those with ergative syntax like Dyirbal, the absolutive marked argument is the one that controls pivot relations, binding, etc, not the ergative argument. Thus, even though the agent is overtly marked as such, it is not the subject. Georgian is a wonderful example of how case morphology can be misalligned with thematic marking: the agent can be in the nominative, ergative, or dative cases depending on verb class and tense. (It's not clear that Georgian even has a subject, though.) BTW, I spoke to a colleague of mine who studies Tagalog and other Philippine languages about the issue of ergativity in Tagalog, and he said more or less definitively that it isn't ergative, but that it's not clear what exactly it is. Since it's not clear it even has a subject, it's impossible to prove it's ergative. ========================================================================= Thomas Wier "I find it useful to meet my subjects personally, Dept. of Linguistics because our secret police don't get it right University of Chicago half the time." -- octogenarian Sheikh Zayed of 1010 E. 59th Street Abu Dhabi, to a French reporter. Chicago, IL 60637