Re: THEORY: final features, moras, and roots [was: it's what I do]
From: | Raymond Brown <ray.brown@...> |
Date: | Friday, October 6, 2000, 6:56 |
At 11:14 pm -0600 5/10/00, dirk elzinga wrote:
>On Thu, 5 Oct 2000, DOUGLAS KOLLER wrote:
>
>> Well I'm still confused. The "mora" thing has always stumped me, but isn't
>> "hatten" two syllables, four morae?
>
>Yup. Here's the representation for the entire word:
Yep - two bimoraic syllables or, if one prefers, two heavy syllables.
> s s
> |\ |\
> m m m m
> /| |/| |
> h a t e n
>
>Notice that the [t] is doubly linked; it is moraic in the first
>syllable and provides the onset for the second syllable. This is
>another definition of geminate: a consonant which is linked to two
>syllables at once. However, this definition of geminate relies on a
>representation which is the product of theoretical assumptions not all
>are willing to make.
Interesting - I must confess I've always understood morae to apply to the
syllabic nucleus and coda (i.e. the rhyme _or_ rime) and to have nothing to
do with the onset. However, I'm always willing to learn something new.
Dirk's analysis above cartainly looks neat :)
I guess at the moment I have to say I neither agree nor disagree with that
analysis of an internal geminate consonant. But IIRC some languages allow
final geminates. Don't they occur, e.g. in Hungarian and Arabic?
[...]
>
>> Sambon ("three bottles") two syllables, four morae? (sa-n-bo-n,
>> pronounced sam-bon).
>
>Right again. Here's the chart:
Yep - just like _cumbunt_ in Latin.
[....]
>> Shinhatsubai ("newly out on the market") four syllables, six morae?
>
>Outstanding! Here it is:
Yep - just what I make it also.
[...]
>
>To sum up: moras are used to reckon syllable weight; that's their
>raison d'etre, theoretically speaking.
Yep - that's what I've understood also. Which, as far as I can see, means
that such morae are also entirely appropriate for the analysis of ancient
Greek verse & prose rhythms, but not for the possible placement of the
pitch accent which was conditioned by syllabic nuclei (i.e. vowels) only.
Ray.
=========================================
A mind which thinks at its own expense
will always interfere with language.
[J.G. Hamann 1760]
=========================================