Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: CHAT: Which world? Which culture?

From:Costentin Cornomorus <elemtilas@...>
Date:Saturday, July 12, 2003, 1:30
Haraldr maelti:

> It is said that language is a mirror of its > speaker's culture.
And verse visa. I.e., language and culture are intertwined.
> In fact, this > sounds so very true to me that I am even > creating an entire world for > my current conlang. On the other hand it seems > to me that there are > people on this list who don't create cultures > when they create languages.
Well, there's no telling, with some people! ;)
> So my question to those fellow conlangers would > be: Which culture do > you mirror into your conlangs? Your native one?
In my opinion, my native country doesn't _have_ its own culture yet, really. Give it a few centuries to settle in.
> Another existing culture > that you deliberately choose?
Sometimes. Clearly, Kerno and Dumnonia are supposed to mirror Cornwall a little.
> Or some ancient culture? Just curious...
Sometimes the mirroring come from in internal desire: a mirroring of the culture that _should_ have existed in the primary world, but does not.
> Another solution to the problem could be to > make a culturally neutral > language -
SNORE!!! Wake me up when it's all over! ;)
> which sounds so extremely impossible > that my writing fingers > keep asking my brain if it really would like to > even mention such a strange idea. *g*
It's impossible only in that we are, by nature, cultural beings. The very _exsistence_ of a language is presupposed by a culture. It may be possible to extirpate some obviously culture specific references or metaphores - but excision of enough stuff to make a language "culture free" will yield a nolanguage. Padraic. ===== beuyont alch geont la ciay la cina mangeiont alch geont y faues la lima; pe' ne m' molestyont que faciont doazque y facyont in rima. .

Reply

Thomas R. Wier <trwier@...>