Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: THEORY: Ergativity and polypersonalism

From:Andreas Johansson <andjo@...>
Date:Thursday, January 20, 2005, 16:43
Quoting Tristan McLeay <conlang@...>:

> > One curious thing about English though is that it's often painted as a > relatively isolating language, but as I understand it (and I might be > *wildly* wrong here, which is the simplest explanation) German tends > not to use its genitive, preferring expressions including 'von', and > doesn't like its simple past tense, preferring expressions paralleling > English past perfects, whereas English enjoys the use of both... OTOH, > I've never heard anyone claiming that German's a relatively isolating > language...
I think the genitive is a bad example, since many would deny that English has an inflectional genitive at all. A little-used on surely beats none! While the German simple past, outside of a couple very common verbs, is indeed little used in spoken German (the spoken varieties of standard High German, at any rate; I should better not make any generalizations about what goes on in dialects), it has much more verbal morphology than English, so it seems less isolating to me.
> BTW---if a language forms everything with clitics (like English seems > to want to), does it necessarily count as isolating or agglutinative or > something, or can it be whatever it darn well feels like based on other > aspects?
I'd consider it isolating - clitics are syntactic words, and isolating/agglutinating primarily refers to syntax, not phonology (or that's my understanding). It's been said that an extremely agglutinating language is indistinguishible from an extremely isolating one, tho. One tangentially interesting thing is that while written English and German tend to be brimful with contractions, at least the later even in highly formal registers, written Swedish tends to have very few except in the most informal writings (chat messages and the like). A sentence like _Jag åkte inte till honom igår_ would in rapid speech come out something like [jA 'OktEntE ten I'go:r`], but even in chat-speak I'd wouldn't contract anything in the written form beyond |till honom|>|till'n|. Andreas

Reply

Ray Brown <ray.brown@...>THEORY isolating & other typologies (was: THEORY: Ergativity and polypersonalism)