Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: shifting usage of "want"

From:ROGER MILLS <rfmilly@...>
Date:Thursday, April 17, 2008, 23:37
David Peterson wrote:
>Rene: ><< >(7a) (unattested) >John ran the race best because most quickly. > >But this would be camouflaged in Dutch because adverbs like these have >the same form as adjectives. I've not been able to find any examples. > >Could you give examples of the other two kinds of adverbs used in this >construction? I can't imagine any other form to be grammatical. > >> > >Let's see... > >(7b) John was fired by his boss because late. >(7c) John couldn't hear Mary because far away. > >Oh, and this could be interesting: > >Rene: ><< >Hier scoorde ik pluspunten want vrouw. >I scored extra points here because woman. > >> > >What controls (or c-commands, if we want to talk about GB) >the thing after /want/? So... > >(8) Sally hated Susie because woman. > >I.e., "Sally hated Susie, because she (Sally) is a woman", or is it >"Sally hated Susie, because she (Susie) is a woman"? > >Let's see what other things we can do with islands... > >(9) Sally told Susie to congratulate Stacy because married. > >Can any of the three of them have just gotten married? > >I'm not good enough at these... Anyone taking a syntax class >right now? >
No, but I still remember of bit of early Chomsky/Lakoff/McCawley.... IIRC René's examples all involve deletion of _same subject_. Yours are ambiguous (and I bet will be difficult for René) because of the multiple subjects. I've written multiple pages on a similar problem in Prevli: the verb /semi/ can mean 'to say' or can be used as an indirect order, 'to tell (s.o. to do s.t.). Gets very gnarly the more clauses you pile up: "she says she thinks she told her to feed her baby". :-)))))