Re: passive ergative?
From: | Henrik Theiling <theiling@...> |
Date: | Monday, May 14, 2007, 22:32 |
Hi!
Jeff Rollin writes:
> A throwaway comment on a Wikipedia page about grammatical voice said
> something like "ergative languages often have a passive voice as well
> as an antipassive", but didn't give any examples.
>
> Does anyone know of an erg lang that has a passive in addition to (or
> instead of) an antipassive, and what the difference between the two
> is?
I will have to cite the same lang twice today :-). Kalaallisut is an
example here: it is ergative and has both antipassive and passive
constructions.
The difference of normal vs. passive is basically the same as in
English active vs. passive, namely a demotion of the A argument to an
oblique argument. The verb becomes intransitive. The antipassive
demotes the P argument:
Abs/Erg Nom/Acc
A P A P
normal: X.ERG Y.ABS X.NOM Y.ACC
passive: Y.ABS X.Oblique Y.NOM X.Oblique
antipassive: X.ABS Y.Oblique
**Henrik