Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: noun compounds

From:John Vertical <johnvertical@...>
Date:Sunday, March 5, 2006, 0:29
>>>In a language like ancient Greek which had real compound >>>nouns you just could not do as this Swedish trick. >> >> >>I read it to mean that "real" compounds exist only in some languages, such >>as Ancient Greek. > >No - what I meant is that in languages that do have compound nouns you do >not AFAIK find compounds split up with a conjunction shoved in the middle.
OK.
> >Is there really some reason why compounds like "watermelon" >wouldn't be >"real"? > >It is a real compound. I do not know why you would think it is not so or >put 'real' in quotes.
>Ray
I don't see any reason either why words like "watermelon" wouldn't be compounds, but you seemed to be saying that they REALLY weren't: "There are epither-noun-constructions, which are different from the so-called compound nouns, but for REAL compound nouns, we have to look at a language such as Greek..." In other words, I assumed you had some specific reason to bring Greek into the discussion. John Vertical

Reply

R A Brown <ray@...>