Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: OT Caution!! IRA funding (was: English word order and bumper stickers)

From:Joe <joe@...>
Date:Saturday, September 18, 2004, 5:54
Thomas R. Wier wrote:

>Roger Mills wrote: > > >>>The word "America", in this context, was almost universally taken >>>by Americans to mean "the American government", whereas it was >>>almost universally taken by non-Americans to mean "the American >>>populace". >>> >>> >>Well, as you see, I fall into the first category; I'm truly >>surprised at the second-- everything one hears, even from the Arab >>world nowadays, certainly suggests to me that non-Americans are >>quite capable of distinguishing the two, indeed eager to do so. >> >> > >In my personal experience, I cannot agree with this second claim. >I mentioned recently my experience in Germany of being blamed for >the firebombings during WWII. I was walking through central Frankfurt >with some people from the conference, and one German mentioned that >he thought downtown Frankfurt was rather ugly. I responded that >that's because of the bombing (which is true, since extremely little >survived it). >
Blamed? Judging from your story, I wouldn't think so. I'd use 'you' to refer a country of which the person I was talking to belonged. Taking personal offence at it is nonsense. And even if he was blaming you, that can scarcely generalise non-Americans.