Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: The Birds and the Bees of Gender

From:Douglas Koller <laokou@...>
Date:Wednesday, March 31, 1999, 3:57
Nik Taylor wrote:

> Fascinating! I'd never even THOUGHT of that as a problem. But now that > I think about it, your absolutely right, why isn't "lettuce" and "rice" > countable? ESPECIALLY lettuce, since it's so large, you can easily have > "one lettuce".
The phenomenon extends as well, since there is a sort of "agreement" that occurs. "Many" and "a few" go with countables; "much" and "a little" go with uncountables (cf. "beaucoup de cafe'" AND "beaucoup de carottes"; "mucho dinero" AND "muchos idiomas"). "A lot of" can go with either (particularly in affirmative sentences). What I find especially interesting is that, while I assume Romance lang speakers are inculcated with the notion of "masculine", "feminine", and "agreement" in primary and secondary education, we never even touched on this in high school English (and judging from Nik's reaction, I take it my high school was not the exception). ESL books, on the other hand, devote at *least* a chapter to the subject. Kou