Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: Conlang Flag: Voting

From:Roger Mills <rfmilly@...>
Date:Saturday, September 11, 2004, 21:29
Shanthanu wrote:

> Do you have any reasons for wanting to remove the curves? I've put up > a > version without curves at > http://home.iitk.ac.in/student/shanth/images/nocurves.png
Well now, _I_ think that's very nice, and hope someone will second the motion. (1) It definitely looks like a flag! (2) It is nicely abstract (and might be somewhat mysterious to the uninitiated), yet symbolically incorporates the original colors and the original concept of two mouths and intertwined tongues. The version with the two characters struck me as cluttered-- esp. the Chinese character, which would probably give the flagmaker a problem. Neither character, I suspect, would show up well on a small version. Also, anything from a modern, living language suggests a favoritism or bias that is surely not intended. Lastly, as was mentioned in connection with some other designs, words don't seem appropriate on a flag. Clearly I don't object to the hieroglyph in the other designs--where it has a more purely symbolic function (even though I suppose it does represent a _word_, albeit a dead one). The other design, with the curvy things, is marginally better, since it stays at an abstract level, but in both designs I think the additions detract from the otherwise very clean appearance. Just my personal feelings, of course.