Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: The.

From:Adrian Morgan <morg0072@...>
Date:Tuesday, May 22, 2001, 11:36
Quoting John Cowan, quoting myself:

> > Consider this. If I said that my waist measurement in centimetres is
...
> It took me many minutes of pondering to get this; the trouble is not > the "the", but the equivocation over "minus", which in this case does > not have its technical meaning, but is a synonym for "without".
It's a contrived example, but I think it illustrates certain facts about language. Here's how it works. The word "minus" is indeed ambiguous, and the rule for resolving ambiguity is to look for clues in the rest of the sentence. The phrase "1977 minus 19" has the form of a standard mathematical statement, and recognising this resolves the ambiguity. But in "1977 minus the 19", the definite article says, "you know which one I'm talking about", which doesn't make sense for subtraction because there isn't an /particular/ 'nineteen' for the article to refer to. So the reader is lead to the other meaning of "minus", viz "without", because in that case there /is/ a particular 'nineteen' that justifies the use of the definite article. Adrian.

Reply

John Cowan <jcowan@...>