Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: Re : Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis

From:Charles <catty@...>
Date:Saturday, October 16, 1999, 0:46
From Http://Members.Aol.Com/Lassailly/Tunuframe.Html wrote:
>=20 > Dans un courrier dat=E9 du 14/10/99 23:47:14 , wwang a =E9crit : >=20 > > I know there are people, and some on this list, who do claim to feel > > differently when they speak one language rather than another. Any > > thoughts? Do these feelings stem from the language itself, and how =
one
> > expresses one's self in it, or is it due to being in a different soc=
ial
> > environment?
> i think a different cultural background makes you think different, > but a different language doesn't.
But learning any second language at all, is (sort of) like a fish jumping out of one pond, nearly suffocating, then flopping into another: he notices water, for the first time.
> however, i also feel that "root words" cover different concepts dependi=
ng
> on languages. you can always derive or combine them to produce > universal concepts any earthling understands but the original word stoc=
ks
> are different. in other words, the classification of items-in-the-world=
differs
> from one lang to another. and i think this is still overlooked.
Semantic space is still unmapped, I suppose, except for a few projects like EuroWordNet. But you are claiming more, that there is something universal ... interesting philosophical question.