Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: Distaste and hostility was Re: a 12th century conlang

From:Sally Caves <scaves@...>
Date:Wednesday, March 24, 1999, 6:12
dunn patrick w wrote:

> It would be interesting to read a psychological study of why people have > such an overtly hostile reaction to the idea of conlanging. > > --Patrick
Hear hear, Patrick. And I'm in the process of writing it. It seems to be something that mostly ladeda academics engage in; I mean, there are many many studies of Tolkien's languages in less prestigious journals than _Exemplaria_. It's the damned theorists of language or of literary criticism that you've got to watch out for. Neither Schnapp nor Yaguello can bring themselves to mention Quenya or Klingon... and yet they seem so content to apply these absolutes to their observations: ALWAYS a bricolage; ALWAYS infantile, ALWAYS amateur. I wish all of you could have come to my talk. I played some Olaetyan soundbytes, Herman. It's as if...well... serious attention paid to linguistic treatment of Tolkien is for those "other" "lesser" critics. The Trekkers and Tolkienites. We language theorists are going to talk about Helene Smith, and how her Martian language is representative of what all those goofy conlangers are doing. Phroka! Sally http://www.frontiernet.net/~scaves/pronouns.html