Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: Missing the sky

From:Lars Henrik Mathiesen <thorinn@...>
Date:Monday, March 11, 2002, 1:55
> Date: Fri, 8 Mar 2002 15:50:32 -0500 > From: Andreas Johansson <and_yo@...> > > Joe Hill wrote: > > [Andreas too:] > > > Why doesn't anybody seem to believe in the "schwa > > > indogermanicus" any longer? Even tho' initial [pxt-] would > > > probably delight a Georgian, doesn't the fact that a vowel turns > > > up in all daughter languages sort of suggest that there were one > > > there right from the start?
> >Becuase of Hittite.
> >Hittite has an /x/ sound where all other IE languages have a vowel. > >As hittite is the earliest attested IE language, and Lanyngeals had > >been put forth before, it makes sense, no?
> Well, I guess it does - otherwise the IEists would reconstruct the > words in question like they do. So, does Hettite have something like > /pxter/ for "father"?
It's a bit more complex than that. From various ablaut series, it's fairly sure that PIE had _something_, or rather three different somethings, that developed like this between consonants: PIE Sanskrit Greek Xe a e/a/o Xo a o eX a: e:/a:/o: oX a: o: X i e/a/o that doesn't say anything about what sort of sounds the X's were. When de Saussure suggested them (in 1878), he just called them coefficients sonantiques. Some of the evidence for the X's being h-like sounds is that PIE TXe becomes Tha in Sanskrit, TTa in Hittite (T = p/t/k), and that some Xe-/Xwe- become ha-/hwe- in Hittite. (The latter was what finally made the theory acceptable, once it was realized how old Hittite was. Before that, PIE was thought to have had unvoiced aspirates that only survived in Sanskrit). For instance, PIE root *h2wes- "to sojourn, remain": Hittite huis-zi, Skt v