Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: Rhys Ifans! Welsh fans, another pronunciation pop question

From:Kris Kowal <cowbertvonmoo@...>
Date:Sunday, November 28, 2004, 7:42
> > > We this side of the Pond would just assume /'ajfAnz/ was an Americanism > > > similar to the way we've heard _Iraq_ pronounced "I wrack" and _Iran_ > > > pronounced "I ran" in newsreels :) > > I have heard the theory expressed that these mispronunciations began as > > deliberate insults, like [ai't&lj@n] for "Italian", and have spread.
No, our pronunciations are just left over from America's isolationist days. Before the World Wars, America shied away from internationalism and the typical American of the time (yeah, some of them are still alive and even attend family gatherings) had no idea how these words should be pronounced so they took their best guess given American English's dreadfully inconsistent pronunciation system and that's what we're stuck with. Also, most Americans are pretty damned lazy/arrogant about international pronunciation. The American palette just "ain't" that flexible. It's social suicide to attempt to pronounce a name correctly in public here. Back in my German classes in High School, I got laughed at a few times for trying to enunciate correctly. Here, in college, my roommates chuckle when I attempt to pronounce Spanish (California is filled to the brim with Spanish names for cities, streets, and geographical landmarks, but our pronunciations are all Americanized). The typical American has no idea what it's like to be surrounded by variety in language and generally doesn't respect such differences. It's an easy arrogance to fall upon when one can drive a week in any direction and everybody's still speaking American. I only know of a handful of cases where Americans have used language to insult another culture. During the World Wars, our Congress passed bills to rename sauerkraut and hamburgers. Recently, Congress passed a bill renaming French fries (pomfrit, chips, whatever) to freedom fries and French toast to freedom toast. Nobody respects the change. We're still eating French fries. Frankly, Congress behaved like a baby and had no business inciting negative sentiment toward France. I'm continuously dismayed that nations, especially my own, behave like small children. Kris. -- (watch the reply to)