Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: Quantifiers and negation with unusual grammatical number

From:Nokta Kanto <red5_2@...>
Date:Wednesday, December 17, 2003, 23:50
>What do I do when I want to negate existence and say "There weren't any >skirts"? "There weren't any skirts" (i.e. skirts didn't exist then) means >something different than the singular "There wasn't any skirt,"
>If I want to say, "People have always wondered if the moon is made out of >green cheese," do I use the plural or the multal?
I think the examples you gave are in the absolutive aspect, meaning they make a generalization or absolute statement about all the things of a given category. This is really distinct from the issue of noun number; often the absolutive case is indicated by something other than noun number. I mention this because, in English at least, it's easy to overlook because the absolutative aspect is mostly implicit. What your description puts in my mind is negated numbers, so you could say "I have not-a-lot of flutes" to mean you have none or a few, and "I have not-just-one flute" to say that you have some or many. Of course, one would have to wonder about the perspicuity of saying "not-a-few".