Re: Analyzing Phonology

 --- Dirk Elzinga skrzypszy:

> As a phonologist, you don't know how it pains me to hear you say this! What a
> golden opportunity! In my own projects, I've always started with some idea of
> what the phonology is going to be and then constructed words which conform to
> that idea -- I've never been able to just start making words to see what
> turned up. I feel in my heart of hearts that should someone work this way,
> the resulting phonology would be completely natural and idiosyncratic -- a
> true reflection in speech sounds of a person's esthetic. You stand on the
> brink of this amazing discovery; I urge you to reconsider your distaste of
> phonology and find out what you have. I think that the process would be
> illuminating. I'd be happy to help if you had questions.
I'm not sure if I agree with you, Dirk. It's true that - thanks to the List - I
have discovered the pleasures of phonology; before that, I thought of it rather
as a pain in the butt, an unpleasant thing that needs to be done but if
possible limited to a minimum.
So yes, I have been doing that, too. Simply pulling words out of the air and
implementing them into my vocabulary for no other reason than that I liked
them.
Without checking or double-checking if they would fit into the undefined
phonological rules of my language.
But does that mean that they don't fit? I don't think so. When browsing through
my vocabulary, I even see the opposite: they fit perfectly, maybe even better
than many words that were created according to the rules. Because the absence
of a clearly defined and deeply elaborated phonology does not necessarily mean
that there is no phonology at all; on the contrary, it exists, and is alive!
But only in one's head, on a strictly intuitive level.

I'm sure this is the case for Arthaey as well. I just can't understand why she
doesn't want to investigate her language manually; after all, it would be great
fun to do so. By having it done by the computer, she misses hours of
interesting, playful, and educative activity. My experience is that this
activity alone creates an very good insight in how the language actually works,
and generates hundreds of new words as a nice side-effect.

Jan

=====
"Originality is the art of concealing your source." - Franklin P. Jones

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Everything you'll ever need on one web page
from News and Sport to Email and Music Charts
http://uk.my.yahoo.com

Replies