Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: Language comparison

From:Sai Emrys <saizai@...>
Date:Tuesday, January 11, 2005, 21:07
> I think the deal is that there are a thousand criteria, possibly more, by > which a human language can be judged.
Mm, quite probably. How many do you need, though, to get a good approximation?
> I cannot concieve of a single, general test of over-all quality. Not that > I cannot think what this test might be, but that I cannot intellectually > accept that such a test could exist.
Also agreed. Hence why I said that there would be multiple "tests of overall quality" - one for every axiomatic set of goals. Quite possibly an infinite number of these, too, though I think most could likely be encompassed by a dozen at most.
> That will be my final word on the subject. Please, please, please, take > this off list. Discussions of optimality are well and good, but we're > getting beyond discussion and into dogma, and that is never fun for > someone outside the conversation to read. Kill it.
Shall I call "Hitler"? :-P - Sai