Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: USAGE: Help with Chinese phrase

From:Tamas Racsko <tracsko@...>
Date:Saturday, September 4, 2004, 7:18
On 3 Sep 2004 Ray Brown <ray.brown@FREE...> wrote:
> On Thursday, September 2, 2004, at 09:38 , Mark Reed wrote: > > [smip] > > But who in the heck designed Pinyin? > > A committee of the People's Republic of China (it was approved by the > Communist National Assembly in 1958).
I think the consonant (onset) notation was heavily influenced by the German transcription. They had colonies in Southern China and they left behind their breweries and transcription system there after their withdrawal. Germans trascribed aspirate -- inaspirate contrast as unvoiced -- voiced (a number of German dialects know inaspirate unvoiced mediae in constrast with aspirate unvoiced tenues) as in current Pinyin while the other systems used a diacritical apostrophe for the aspiration (or simply neglegted the denotation). It seems that it was a principle by the design of Pinyin that onset consonant digraphs are to be avoided. Except, of course, the retroflex diacritic-like marker "h". This marker was also of German inspiration -- however re-spelled according to English orthography --, cf. Pinyin "ch-" ~ German transcription "tsch-", P. "sh-" ~ GT. "sch-". The "monographic" principle and the German tradition led to the choice of "z" and "c". Both letters have /ts/ quality in German ("z" always, "c" before front vowels). For non-Germans, "z" implies a quality of voicedness, therefore it was choosen for the unaspirate variant. It was the "monographic" principle again to choose "x-" for the English-German "hs-" digraph. After the above was done, two onset consonants still had no their own letter: /ts\/ and /z`/. And there were only a small number of unallocated Latin letter to choose from. Letter "q" was choose for /ts\/ either for the Albanian-Chinese friendship or for its resemblance to a Cyrillic letter; it is not too important to know the exact reason because it was only a secondary solution for the "odds and ends". The basis of "r" = /z`/ assignment was IMHO the phonetic similarity of /z`/ and /r`/, i.e. "r" stands for 'the left- over sound that is retroflex, therefore has an "r"-like quality'.

Reply

Ray Brown <ray.brown@...>