Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: Click consonants

From:Roger Mills <romilly@...>
Date:Saturday, December 13, 2003, 18:19
Herman Miller wrote:
> > If the difference isn't phonemic in a particular language, it might be
nice
> to specify whether the accompaniment is voiced or voiceless, velar or > uvular, aspirated or unaspirated, in free variation, etc., but that's a > matter of how much detail the author wants to put into the phonological > description.
But without that information, the description of the language is incomplete; for sure, someone learning to speak the lang. needs the information. (Though it may be incidental to someone who's merely analyzing it to see, for ex., what the word-order rules are.) Some languages distinguish between [t_d] (dental), [t_-]
> (alveolar), and [t`] (retroflex), but that doesn't mean that you need to > specify whether your language's /t/ is dental or alveolar if the
difference
> isn't phonemic. >
FWIW, in Malay/Indonesian, /t/ is dental but /d/ is alveolar. If you don't learn that, you'll "sound funny"-- a minor, but unecessary, fault.

Replies

Herman Miller <hmiller@...>
Steg Belsky <draqonfayir@...>