Re: OT: Two Towers movie

> Personally, I wanted to see more ents, and I couldn't figure
> out why they
> changed Faramir's character so much. Other than that, the changes were
> defensible and mostly inconsequential.
Personally, I am yet to see a defense of the exorcism scene other than
'make your own version of that piece and we'll see who's the better
one'.

Also IMO while the oher changes are defensible, I really don't see the
point of most of them. Tolkien, with all his talk and description, is
IMO very cinematographic, apart from a few real difficult scenes such as
the Council of Elrond (which was awful in FR) and entrance into Edoras
(which I liked a lot, except for the fact that the barn on top of the
hill was a bit *too* much like the Lee picture, and it's certainly not
'lihte se leoma / ofer landa fela').

Pavel
--
Pavel Iosad               pavel_iosad@mail.ru

Nid byd, byd heb wybodaeth
                 --Welsh saying

Reply