Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: Subordinate clauses

From:Andreas Johansson <andjo@...>
Date:Monday, June 21, 2004, 16:54
Quoting Carsten Becker <post@...>:

> Roger Mills: I wasn't sure about this, as I said, so I looked up in my > grammar what the relative pronoun refers to. And they wrote that the > relative pronoun always refers to the subject of the main clause -- if I > understood that correctly.
I'm afraid I believe you did not; it would mean that the following sentence from my German grammar were agrammatical: Ich hab mich sehr über den Roman gefreut, den du mir geschenkt hast. Here, the relative pronoun refers to the _object_ of the main main clause, namely _den Roman_. My grammar does not seem to say anything explicitly about whether the relative can refer to a possessive genitive, but it takes the trouble to point out explicitly that it _can_ refered to the thing possessed. It also lists the example sentence: Ich weiss nichts von dem, was er erzählt. were the relative pronoun refers to _von dem_. I find it hard to believe that prepositional phrases with _von_ would here be treated differently from genitives, or that _was_ and _der_ would behave differently. I shall try and keep my opens for any conclusive examples in actual German texts. Andreas